Find a service

T. 0114 276 5555

The Complications Of Business Lease Renewals

Share this page:

When a lease on commercial premises comes under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 (LTA), the grounds on which the landlord may oppose the tenant’s application for a new lease when the lease expires are limited. One of the grounds that is available to a landlord wishing to take possession at the end of the lease is that the landlord requires the property for the purpose of carrying on its own business.

hlw Keeble Hawson LogoA recent case in the Court of Appeal has highlighted that this is not always straightforward.  A landlord opposed the application of its tenant for a new lease. The tenant argued that the landlord could not do this, relying on a provision in the LTA that prevents a landlord from recovering possession from a tenant in order to carry on its own business if the landlord itself has not been a ‘competent landlord’ for the previous five years.

In this case, the landlord was itself a tenant and its lease was shortly coming up for renewal. However, it had not yet taken action to renew the lease. This proved fatal to the landlord’s attempt to oppose the tenant’s lease renewal because the LTA requires the competent landlord to have at least 14 months’ remaining title in the property. The landlord’s own lease did not comply with this requirement and it could not therefore oppose the tenant’s application for a new lease because it could not satisfy the ‘five-year’ rule.

Andrew McKenzie Smith, Partner in hlw Keeble Hawsons’s property litigation team:

“In this case, the landlord should have obtained a new lease before seeking to obtain possession of the property from its tenant. It now faces the prospect of a lengthy wait before it can again seek possession of the premises.  Great care must be exercised to ensure that the necessary steps are taken in accordance with the LTA when seeking to obtain possession.”

Please contact Andrew McKenzie Smith on 0114 276 5555 or on if you want any further information on this or any other legal issue concerning business lease renewals.

Share this page:

Get in Touch